Southern Legitimacy Statement:
I have noticed that somehow the most Southern state, Florida, is generally not thought of as a part of the South. Except for that portion known as South Georgia. How that happened I am not sure. I have lived in South Florida for five years. The accents here are of the boroughs of New York, the Caribbean, South America and a few, like mine, from Chicago’s North Side. (Chicagoans from the South Side never leave the city because the many railroad crossings and ethnic rivalries keep them close to home.)
My mother was born in Kentucky. Her emotional attachments were Southern, her political affinities were Democratic. Her uncle was Kentucky Senator Thomas Paynter. But she was also a Catholic and that seemed to make her an outsider in her own land. She used to tell of crossing the frozen Ohio River to attend mass in Portsmouth, Ohio. Her religion was the only thing that rivaled her love of the South. Except, of course, for those burning crosses she saw as a child on the hills above town.
The South may be arbitrarily designated as below the Mason-Dixon line but I can assure you that places like Cairo, Illinois qualify on every other basis than geography– values, food, songs, religion, and family. Hound dogs, dead mules, moonshine, poetry, love of language, orneriness, and similar Southern characteristics are all there as well. So are corn bread, grits, catfish, and the push for canonization of Flannery O’Connor.
The South is more diverse than it wants to admit. It enjoys putting on that twisting-toe-in-the-dirt-aw-shucks flimflam then throwing in a allusion to a little known Shakespearean poem. It hides a sense of superiority in the guise of national victim. But it is just a bit too proud to get away with it. I love the South and have trekked its hills and woods, waded in clouds of tadpoles in its creeks, and slobbered BBQ sauce or butter all over my shirt depending on whether ribs or crawfish were on the plate.
In Chicago there is a saying, “We don’t want nobody nobody sent.” Which means that unless my people know you and vouch for you I don’t want anything to do with you. The South has a similar philosophy and breaks from it just as often as they do in Chicago.